I saw this post on AppleMatters today about the Macs being more cost effective than PCs. This is a brief response. I have a lot more to say about this matter, but don’t feel like spending more time on it.
I generally prefer Apple over the competition for a plethora of reasons, but I’m gonna play devil’s advocate on this one, being a grad student & strapped for $$$. Despite the introduction of the Mac mini and cheaper iBooks, Apple is still high end and more expensive than a cheap Windows or Linux box. The cost is not up front, their prices are competitive for what you get. Their chip speeds will generally be slower, but since the OS is better, you don’t usually notice the difference (maybe for some gaming apps).
The cost is mainly in the service. Servicing a PC is usually cheaper. PC components are cheap and you can often do the labor yourself. Even on laptops, where you can’t do the labor as easily, the service packages on most brands are better than Apple’s, which is only once year, unless you pay more for extended, which I highly recommend, given that minimum cost of service is generally their flat rate of about $300.
For quality components, OSs, UIs, etc. Apple’s top notch. You will generally feel better and enjoy working on the Mac. Things tend to be where they should be intuitively, and they’ve gone through great pains to make it feel that way for just about everyone from the tech expert to the computer illiterate. But their service is really not very good for a company that prides itself on user friendliness. It’s expensive and hard to get.
I don’t recommend Macs to students like myself anymore, as spending an hour or two on the phone or at the genius bar only to be told you need to drop the mandatory $300 to have a fan replaced is not the kind of thing someone strapped for cash and time can do. If you have cash, buy an Apple, and a BMW to plug yer iPod into. If not, the cheapo Windows boxes and minimal time invested in tuning & security is often the way to go. I still prefer Apple, but I work on Winows at work and XP is pretty decent.
I had to shell out $300 last year when my logic board died. I ended up getting the money refunded, which took like 6 months, through their iBook logic board refund campaign, since it turned out thousands of the iBooks in the batch mine was from had faulty boards, but until they made the official refund announcement it was $300 just to look at the thing. The geniuses were of no help. The battery on my iPod is dying now, and although I bought the extended service thing for it (~$60 I think) they give you a hell of a time about replacing it, requiring you to leave it with them for a few days to run diagnostics. This includes erasing all your music, which at the time, I didn’t have 100% backed up, so I had to go home, back it up and I haven’t made time to get out to the Apple store to get it checked up yet. I need to do that… and get the oxygen emissions sensor replaced on my car so the damn check engine light shuts off…
Oh, and regarding the author’s comments on the security of the IE 6 browser, that’s just incorrect. The security it uses for sending info encrypted is the same as any other browser, https is standard stuff. Granted, people may be spending more time trying to hack the browser and exploit its security flaws, but all browsers are buggy, all of them can be tricked.