EECS 349 Project proposal peer review

Due 11:59PM Tuesday, May 9

In this assignment, you will review three project proposals and give the group feedback.

The first step is to find out which proposals you will review. Open the file aa_proposal_reviews.csv in the project proposals folder in Canvas. Find the last three digits of your net ID in the first column -- you are assigned to review the three proposals in that row. You can find all the proposal documents in the proposal reviews folder. In addition to turning in your review, you must also send the review via e-mail to at least one of members of the team you reviewed. Use the names in the PDF, or in the file name, along with the NU Directory or Canvas, to find contact information for one of the students.

The peer reviews are brief. Tell the other group:

  1. How they could improve their write-up. Are any portions unclear, or underdeveloped? How should they alter their writing approach in their remaining project reports? (2 sentences)
  2. Whether you like their project idea, and pros and cons (2 sentences)
  3. What advice you have for them in order to have a successful project by the end of the quarter (3 sentences)
It is possible, although unlikely, that you will be assigned to review your own proposal. In that case, go ahead and review your own proposal (self-review can be very valuable).

It is also possible but unlikely that you will be assigned two reviews from the same group. In that case, please pick another review at random from the directory and review that instead.

Submission Instructions

For each of the three peer reviews you are assigned, you should paste into the text box in Canvas two things:

  1. The e-mail address(es) that you sent the peer review to.
  2. The text of the peer review